The Quotient Rule and Combined Rules
Key Terms
- The quotient rule applies when a function is the ratio of two differentiable functions: y = f(x)/g(x).
- Formula: d/dx[f/g] = (f′g − fg′) / g². “Low d-high minus high d-low, all over low squared.”
- The order of subtraction matters — it is f′g − fg′, not fg′ − f′g.
- Many quotients can also be differentiated by rewriting as a product with a negative power (using the chain rule), but the quotient rule is often more direct.
- Combined rules
- means applying chain, product, and quotient rules together for complex functions.
Quotient rule: d/dx[f(x)/g(x)] = [f′(x)g(x) − f(x)g′(x)] / [g(x)]²
| y = f/g | f′, g′ | dy/dx = (f′g − fg′)/g² |
|---|---|---|
| (x + 1)/(x − 2) | f′ = 1, g′ = 1 | [1(x − 2) − (x + 1)(1)] / (x − 2)² = −3/(x − 2)² |
| x²/(3x + 1) | f′ = 2x, g′ = 3 | [2x(3x + 1) − 3x²] / (3x + 1)² = (3x² + 2x)/(3x + 1)² |
| 1/(x² + 1) | f′ = 0, g′ = 2x | [0 · (x² + 1) − 1 · 2x]/(x² + 1)² = −2x/(x² + 1)² |
Worked Example 1 — Simple rational function
Question: Differentiate y = (x + 1)/(x − 2).
Identify: f = x + 1, f′ = 1; g = x − 2, g′ = 1.
Apply: dy/dx = [1(x − 2) − (x + 1)(1)] / (x − 2)² = (x − 2 − x − 1)/(x − 2)²
Answer: dy/dx = −3/(x − 2)²
Worked Example 2 — Polynomial over linear
Question: Differentiate y = x²/(3x + 1).
Identify: f = x², f′ = 2x; g = 3x + 1, g′ = 3.
Apply: dy/dx = [2x(3x + 1) − x²(3)] / (3x + 1)² = (6x² + 2x − 3x²)/(3x + 1)²
Answer: dy/dx = (3x² + 2x)/(3x + 1)²
Worked Example 3 — Chain rule inside quotient rule
Question: Differentiate y = (x² + 1)3 / (2x − 1).
Identify: f = (x² + 1)³, f′ = 3(x² + 1)²(2x) = 6x(x² + 1)²; g = 2x − 1, g′ = 2.
Apply: dy/dx = [6x(x² + 1)²(2x − 1) − (x² + 1)³(2)] / (2x − 1)²
Factor: = (x² + 1)²[6x(2x − 1) − 2(x² + 1)] / (2x − 1)²
= (x² + 1)²[12x² − 6x − 2x² − 2] / (2x − 1)² = (x² + 1)²(10x² − 6x − 2) / (2x − 1)²
Motivation: Why the Quotient Rule?
When a function is written as a fraction of two expressions in x, neither factor is constant, so you cannot differentiate numerator and denominator separately. The quotient rule provides the correct formula derived from first principles by expressing f/g as f × g−1 and applying the product rule.
Deriving the Quotient Rule
Write y = f/g = f × g−1. By the product rule: dy/dx = f′ × g−1 + f × (−g−2g′) = f′/g − fg′/g² = (f′g − fg′)/g². This is the quotient rule.
Step-by-Step Method
- Label: Write f = numerator, g = denominator.
- Differentiate: Find f′ and g′ separately (use chain rule if needed).
- Substitute: dy/dx = (f′g − fg′) / g².
- Simplify: Expand the numerator, collect like terms, and factor if possible.
Differentiate y = (2x − 3)/x².
f = 2x − 3, f′ = 2. g = x², g′ = 2x.
dy/dx = [2 × x² − (2x − 3) × 2x] / x4
= [2x² − 4x² + 6x] / x4 = (−2x² + 6x)/x4
= x(−2x + 6)/x4 = (−2x + 6)/x³ = 2(3 − x)/x³
Find the x-coordinate of any stationary point of y = x/(x² + 1).
f = x, f′ = 1; g = x² + 1, g′ = 2x.
dy/dx = [1(x² + 1) − x(2x)] / (x² + 1)² = (x² + 1 − 2x²)/(x² + 1)² = (1 − x²)/(x² + 1)²
Set dy/dx = 0: 1 − x² = 0 → x² = 1 → x = ±1.
Combined Rules: Chain + Product + Quotient
Complex functions may require multiple rules applied together. The general approach:
- If the function is a quotient, use the quotient rule as the outer operation.
- If the numerator or denominator is itself a composite function, apply the chain rule when differentiating that part.
- If the numerator or denominator is a product, apply the product rule to differentiate it.
Always work systematically: identify all components, differentiate each one, then assemble using the appropriate formula.
Differentiate y = x(x + 1) / (x² + 1).
Numerator f = x(x + 1) = x² + x, so f′ = 2x + 1. g = x² + 1, g′ = 2x.
dy/dx = [(2x + 1)(x² + 1) − (x² + x)(2x)] / (x² + 1)²
Numerator: 2x³ + 2x + x² + 1 − 2x³ − 2x² = −x² + 2x + 1
dy/dx = (−x² + 2x + 1) / (x² + 1)²
Summary
Quotient rule: d/dx[f/g] = (f′g − fg′)/g². Steps: label f, g; find f′, g′ (chain rule if needed); substitute; simplify. Combined rules: apply quotient rule as the outer structure, using chain and product rules within the numerator and denominator as required.
Mastery Practice
-
Fluency
Differentiate each function using the quotient rule.
- (a) y = (x + 1)/(x − 2)
- (b) y = x²/(3x + 1)
- (c) y = (2x − 3)/x²
- (d) y = 1/(x² + 1)
-
Fluency
Differentiate each rational function. Simplify your answer fully.
- (a) y = (3x + 2)/(x + 1)
- (b) y = x/(x² + 4)
- (c) y = (x² − 1)/(x + 1) [Hint: simplify by factoring the numerator first]
-
Fluency
Differentiate. Express your answers with positive indices where relevant.
- (a) y = 4/x²
- (b) y = (x + 1)/x³
- (c) y = 3/√x
-
Understanding
Find all x-values where dy/dx = 0 (turning points) for each function.
Method: Apply the quotient rule, then set the numerator of dy/dx equal to zero.- (a) y = x/(x² + 1)
- (b) y = x²/(x − 1)
- (c) y = (x − 1)/(x² + 3)
-
Understanding
Find the equation of the tangent to each curve at the given point.
- (a) y = (x + 1)/(x − 2) at x = 3
- (b) y = x²/(x + 1) at x = 1
- (c) y = 1/(x² + 1) at x = 0
-
Understanding
Simplify the derivative. Show that the quotient rule result can be simplified to the given form.
- (a) Show that d/dx[(x² + 1)/(x)] = (x² − 1)/x². Verify by rewriting y = x + x−1 first.
- (b) Show that d/dx[(2x − 3)/x²] = 2(3 − x)/x³.
-
Understanding
Chain rule combined with quotient rule.
Differentiate each function (the numerator or denominator requires chain rule).
- (a) y = (2x + 1)³ / x
- (b) y = √x / (x² + 1)
- (c) y = (x² + 3)² / (x − 1)
-
Problem Solving
Product rule combined with quotient rule.
Differentiate each function, which involves both a product structure and a quotient.
- (a) y = x(x + 1) / (x² + 1)
- (b) y = x²(x − 1) / (2x + 3)
-
Problem Solving
Related rates using the quotient rule.
Challenge. The concentration of a drug in the bloodstream at time t hours is modelled by C(t) = 5t / (t² + 4) (in mg/L).- (a) Find C′(t) using the quotient rule.
- (b) Find the time at which the concentration is at its maximum (set C′(t) = 0).
- (c) Find the maximum concentration.
- (d) Is the concentration increasing or decreasing at t = 3? Justify your answer.
-
Problem Solving
Full combined rules question.
For the function f(x) = x²(x + 1)3 / (2x − 1):
- (a) Identify the numerator u and denominator v. Find u′ using the product and chain rule.
- (b) Apply the quotient rule to find f′(x).
- (c) Factor f′(x) as fully as possible.
- (d) Find the gradient of the curve at x = 1.